Two topical male products compared. Side-by-side analysis by the WellnessChecked editorial team.
✍️ WellnessChecked Editorial Team✅ Side-by-Side Comparison📅 Updated October 2026
Affiliate disclosure: We earn a commission if you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. We only cover products from brands we have affiliate relationships with, so our top picks are the best of the products we cover, not of every product on the market.
⚡ Quick AnswerLast Reviewed: October 2026
Both are on-demand topical products from Leading Edge Health with L-arginine and menthol, and neither has a published study. We don't name a winner: choose by ingredients and texture, and expect the main noticeable effect to be a cooling or tingling sensation.
Neither product is a treatment for erectile dysfunction; see a doctor about persistent symptoms.
⚡ Quick Verdict
There's no clear winner. VigRX Oil adds red ginseng and ginkgo (per third-party listings); Erectin Gel is a water-based, silicone-free gel with saffron and vitamin C. There's little evidence that L-arginine or these herbs work when applied to the skin, so treat either as a sensation product.
A topical VigRX-brand product containing L-arginine, red ginseng, ginkgo, menthol and other botanicals (per third-party listings), applied before sex. No amounts disclosed and no published study.
A water-based, silicone-free topical gel with L-arginine, menthol, saffron, vitamin C and plant extracts, applied before sex. No concentrations disclosed and no published study.
Both are low-commitment ways to try a topical product, but neither has evidence that it improves erections. Patch-test first, and buy from the official site so the guarantee applies.
Neither has a published study, and we don't rate one above the other. The choice comes down to ingredients and texture.
VigRX Oil lists L-arginine, shea butter, Korean red ginseng, ginkgo, aloe, licorice, wild yam, menthol and raspberry (third-party listings, no amounts). Erectin Gel lists saffron, L-arginine, vitamin C, bearberry, menthol, aloe, algae extract and mango butter in a water-based, silicone-free gel (no amounts).
There's no reason to use both at once, and layering two menthol products raises the chance of irritation.
From the official VigRX Oil website. A third-party review describes a 67-day money-back guarantee; check the current conditions on the site before ordering.
Both are external products. Patch-test first, don't apply to broken skin or sores, and stop if irritation or a rash develops. Menthol can transfer to a partner. Check the label for latex-condom compatibility. Persistent erection problems are worth a doctor's visit.
Disclaimer: This comparison is produced by the WellnessChecked editorial team. None of the products mentioned are medicines. Not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease. These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. Individual results may vary. Always consult a qualified healthcare professional before starting any supplement program. We earn affiliate commissions on purchases made via links on this page — at no extra cost to you. Full disclaimer →
We'd like to use Google Analytics cookies to count visits and see which pages are useful. Analytics records the pages you view, which can include health topics. They stay off unless you accept. Privacy Policy