Two herbal erection-support supplements from the same maker compared. Side-by-side analysis by the WellnessChecked editorial team.
✍️ WellnessChecked Editorial Team✅ Side-by-Side Comparison📅 Updated October 2026
Affiliate disclosure: We earn a commission if you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. We only cover products from brands we have affiliate relationships with, so our top picks are the best of the products we cover, not of every product on the market.
⚡ Quick AnswerLast Reviewed: October 2026
VigRX Plus is our top pick among male sexual-health supplements and Erectin is our alternative pick. The main difference is evidence: VigRX Plus has one small published placebo-controlled trial of the product, while Erectin has none, though Erectin's label does list a dose for each ingredient.
Neither product is a treatment for erectile dysfunction; see a doctor about persistent symptoms.
⚡ Quick Verdict
We prefer VigRX Plus because the product itself has a published trial (75 men, 12 weeks, better erection scores than placebo); that trial was small and used an older, higher-dose formula. Erectin is a reasonable alternative if you want every dose on the label, but most of its herbs are dosed well below what studies used.
An herbal blend (damiana, Asian red ginseng, muira puama, hawthorn, catuaba, saw palmetto, ginkgo and Bioperine) from Leading Edge Health. It's one of the few products in this category with a published placebo-controlled trial of the product itself: 75 men, 12 weeks, better erection scores than placebo. The trial was small and used an older, higher-dose formula.
A herbal softgel from Leading Edge Health with 10 botanicals (including ginkgo, hawthorn, saw palmetto and tribulus) plus BioPerine, with every dose on the label. No published trial of the product, and most herbs are well below the doses used in human studies.
VigRX Plus is our top pick among male sexual-health supplements, with modest expectations given its one small trial. Buy from the official site so the 67-day guarantee applies and to avoid counterfeits.
We prefer VigRX Plus because the product has a published placebo-controlled trial; Erectin has none. Erectin is our alternative pick and lists its doses, which the VigRX Plus sales page doesn't.
Both are herbal blends from Leading Edge Health with overlapping herbs (ginkgo, ginseng, hawthorn, saw palmetto, muira puama, catuaba, damiana). VigRX Plus is a pill taken twice a day; Erectin is a two-softgel serving that also contains tribulus, Cuscuta and epimedium, with doses on the label.
We don't recommend it. They share several herbs, including ginkgo, so combining them doubles up on ingredients that can affect bleeding and blood pressure. Ask a healthcare professional first.
From the official VigRX Plus website. Its guarantee requires empty containers to reach the warehouse within 67 days of delivery, excludes shipping and is limited to one order per customer; the terms don't say they cover third-party purchases. Counterfeits with hidden ED drugs have been found, which is another reason to buy direct.
Both contain ginkgo, which can raise bleeding risk with blood thinners or before surgery, and ginseng and hawthorn, which can interact with diabetes and heart medicines. Erectin also contains tribulus and horny goat weed (rare liver and heart-rhythm reports) plus soy and bovine gelatin. Persistent erection problems can be an early sign of heart disease, so see a doctor.
Disclaimer: This comparison is produced by the WellnessChecked editorial team. None of the products mentioned are medicines. Not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease. These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. Individual results may vary. Always consult a qualified healthcare professional before starting any supplement program. We earn affiliate commissions on purchases made via links on this page — at no extra cost to you. Full disclaimer →
We'd like to use Google Analytics cookies to count visits and see which pages are useful. Analytics records the pages you view, which can include health topics. They stay off unless you accept. Privacy Policy